
New York City, 1890:
The only good part about Loring Robertson being dead was that he got to miss the whole crazy drama that soon followed. His six relatives didn’t.
They had all lined up in a New York court, expecting a slice of Robertson’s millions. What they hadn’t expected was the sudden appearance of a wife. Robertson, they thought, didn’t have one.
Sixty-one-year-old Loring Andrews Robertson had become a “financial giant of the leather trade,” as a writer would later say (in a book charmingly titled “History of the Swamp,” but that’s another story). Born in 1828 in Windham, New York, Robertson had left his father’s tannery business and moved to the City in 1857, opening his own tannery at the age of 29. That firm dissolved just five years later, but Loring persevered and in 1870 formed tanning company Robertson & Hoople. He became one of the first to use hemlock for tanning, a cheaper alternative to oak, although it turned the leather redder – a product sometimes marketed as “imitation Moroccan leather.” And Robertson amassed a fortune selling those reddish hides in the South, where the Civil War had left many “too poor to buy oak leather.”
Frugal but quietly philanthropic, Robertson kept his days simple, tending to business and occasionally visiting friends. The only club he frequented was a trade establishment known as the Hide and Leather Club. He didn’t bother with a house, housekeeper, and cook; the confirmed bachelor simply moved from upscale hotel to upscale hotel, making each one his home for a year or so before changing residences.
Robertsons’ life was going along swimmingly. Until October 10, 1890, that is, when he was found dead in his bed at Brooklyn’s lavish St. George Hotel.

Robertson had complained of feeling unwell for several days, and everyone knew he suffered from asthma, but his sudden demise was completely unexpected. An autopsy assigned the cause to heart disease. Robertson himself apparently hadn’t expected the end to come so suddenly, either; he hadn’t bothered to leave a will. What he did leave was a bloody fortune, variously estimated at between $5 and $15 million dollars.
The news rocked New York City. Three days after Robertson’s death, speeches at the Hide and Leather Club extolled his virtues, dubbing him the “Little Giant of the Swamp.” A simple funeral was arranged in Windham, New York.
On December 12, six relatives from New York and Vermont assembled solemnly in the appropriate Brooklyn court, petitioning for letters of administration as his heirs. Then two lawyers representing a “wife” showed up.

Byron W. Cohen and John F. Baker were considered respectable attorneys, with an office at 156 Broadway. They presented the court with the wife’s own signed petition for Letters of Administration; their client, they said, was still too prostrated by grief to show up herself. The papers likened it to “a bombshell in an ambuscade.”
Proof of a marriage? There wasn’t any, they frankly admitted. But “Helen Robertson,” the grieving widow, had come to a “verbal contract and a mutual agreement” with Robertson, they alleged, which in the eyes of the law would have been enough. Her maiden name was Helen Brewer (one news column said Bremer) – a woman the millionaire had met back in Windham, and a known “skeleton in [Robertson’s] bachelor closet.”
According to her lawyers, young “Helen” had been 25 and a “lady of character and refinement” when she’d first made Robertsons’ acquaintance four years earlier. Robertson, at the time, had been 56. He’d furnished her with money and an apartment, and they’d lived together “with a perfect (though secret) understanding that she should be regarded as his wife.”
The heirs were . . . well, skeptical. They pooled their money and hired investigators to dig further. For weeks, however, the mysterious “Mrs. Helen Robertson” never showed her face in public. Detectives even followed every veiled woman who showed up in court to watch the proceedings, just in case, with no success.
Then a reporter for the New York Herald named “L. Allen” (later revealed to be Louis Allen Newcome, a private detective employed by the heirs) stumbled across the first clue to “Helen”’s real identity.

Reporter Allen/Newcome had been dispatched on what he considered an “unpleasant assignment” at Tom Gould’s basement dive at 372 Sixth Avenue, near West 23rd Street. This was a notorious drinking establishment, known for its slippery proprietor, its assortment of “loose” women, and its resident cat and pet monkey.
It was long after midnight, and Tom Gould’s establishment was packed. Allen found himself seated at a table with two women and a pair of men. One of the females was Flo Raymond, a “well known woman about town.” Her pretty blue-eyed companion, Cassie Brooks, had “a little upturned nose” and was about 25. Cassie’s blonde hair, the reporter noted, was cut short and “frizzed in the ‘chippy’ fashion,” a highly-crimped style associated with less-respectable women at the time.

The foursome consumed several bottles of wine together, but proved unable to pay their bill when settling time rolled around. The waiter and bouncer were both rolling up their sleeves, preparing to “settle” things in their own way, when Cassie piped up, announcing she was Loring Robertson’s widow and expected soon to inherit millions. “Look at these diamond drops if you don’t believe me,” she cried, displaying her sparkly earrings.

Proprietor Tom Gould himself stepped in, and the “widow” promptly threw her arms around his neck and whispered something in his ear. “That wine is on the house,” Gould finally grumbled. The foursome left. But Allen had overheard the whole exchange. And Cassie Brooks’ boasting declaration was the clue that would uncover the whole unsavory tale.
A few days later, reporter-slash-investigator Allen tracked down Flo Raymond and paid a visit to her flat at 145 W. Sixteenth Street. It was nine p.m. by the time he arrived, but she welcomed him warmly; “it is her business to entertain wayfarers,” he observed dryly in his report. A bottle of champagne was opened, and Flo grew talkative. Allen inquired about her companion, Cassie Brooks. Flo agreed to arrange a meeting.
That meeting, however, didn’t take place right away. Flo complained to Allen that poor Cassie had encountered a bit of trouble. “Some people got her to claim that she was a rich man’s widow,” Flo admitted. And though that bogus claim had been settled for $50,000, the lawyers had made off with the bulk of it, leaving Cassie just $15,000. Flo and Cassie had gone to Philadelphia to confront the originator of the whole scheme, but it had done no good.
By now, the heirs had a whole team of investigators trailing the suspicious attorneys. On January 6, 1891, attorney Cohen was followed across town from his Broadway office to a boarding house at 94 Clinton Place. Cohen remained at the boarding house for two solid hours before finally going back to his home at 209 E. 52nd Street.
It was Cassie, it turned out, who was renting that “first floor front” apartment, with a bookkeeper named William Ellis who she passed off as her husband. Cassie had assured the landlady she was the widow of a very wealthy merchant, but was keeping her marriage to Ellis quiet while the estate was in litigation.
Cassie’s latest romance would be short-lived. Not long after lawyer Cohen’s visit, Cassie and Ellis got into a row that left Cassie “shamefully beaten” and unconscious on the floor. Ellis took off, and a week later Cassie left, too, taking a new apartment at 136 – 15th Street.
On the evening of January 13, the investigators tracked lawyers Cohen and Baker to a room at the Grand Union Hotel. The attorneys spent two hours there with Cassie, remaining until almost midnight – “a council of war on the eve of giving battle,” as the reporter put it. Also present at this meeting was a Mr. “L.W. Williams” – a man about 45, not quite six feet tall, with short, curly brown hair and “a suspiciously black beard.”
The following day, Cassie – wearing a “sad, distant expression” – entered the Wall Street offices of Lockwood & Crain, attorneys for the heirs, on the arm of that same dignified older man. Even investigator Allen was, for a moment, nearly convinced by the “widow’s” show.

The private eyes continued to follow Cassie and her associates for the rest of the evening, discovering eventually that the man masquerading as her protector wasn’t “Williams” at all, but James W. Daskam — the “black sheep” of a respectable Connecticut family, whose intemperate habits had cost him both his business and many friends.
As for Cassie, investigators found she’d apparently been born in a working-class New York suburb known as Williamsburg, the daughter of James Leigh, a mechanic. She’d run away from home at about age 16 with the son of a wealthy merchant, returning home a few months later. Thereafter, she’d moved into New York City, where she took to frequenting a “notorious dance hall” near the Bowery. She became a regular in Tom Gould’s dive and took up with a succession of men, including a wealthy elderly man from Savannah who briefly brought her south with him. But that arrangement had lasted only about a year until some of the man’s valuables disappeared, and he washed his hands of her. Returning to New York, Cassie may have married a banjo player named Brooks (a surname she continued to use), but she eventually “wandered up town” where she made a living wheedling money from unsuspecting men. “She made great gains and spent them fast,” the reporter summarized.
“Helen Brewer” (the name Cassie had adopted while pretending to be Robertson’s wife) turned out to be a real woman – another blue-eyed beauty who’d lived in Windham at the same time as Loring Robertson. And reporter Allen claimed he’d actually found her. After “a life of shame and dissipation,” Helen was now living in northern New York under a false name (he said), but promised to come down to the city and “scratch the woman’s eyes out” if Cassie didn’t recant her false story.
As for the lawyers, both pleaded ignorance. Cohen claimed to have been introduced to Cassie only by an unidentified “friend.”
His investigation complete, reporter Allen/Newcome spread the entire sordid tale across the pages of the New York Herald on March 27, 1891. This was “a gigantic and ingenious conspiracy,” the paper enthused, “on a scale without parallel in the history of litigation in New York.” Cassie Brooks was described as a “notorious woman” from “Tom Gould’s dive” – a place apparently notorious enough in its own right not to require further description. “The Herald has done its part. Let the law undertake the rest,” the lengthy piece concluded.
The paper published a follow-up piece the next day, noting that all the alleged participants had quickly “made themselves scarce.” Ellis, the former boyfriend who’d beaten Cassie into unconsciousness, claimed to know nothing about the woman. Cassie herself had spent the day the story came out “weeping in her room,” then refused two further visits by the reporter. Williams/Daskam, her partner in the charade, had spent the night at a hotel under an assumed name, then vanished. Attorney Cohen was missing from his law office. Lawyer Baker assured the inquisitive reporter that he’d merely made a court appearance at the request of his partner, and had since withdrawn as Cassie’s counsel. Lawyers for the heirs declined comment, citing promises of confidentiality regarding settlement negotiations. Tom Gould, “famous publican and friend of sinners,” assured the reporter that Cassie Brooks was “as fine a lady as ever stepped up Sixth avenue,” but denied knowing anything more about her “business and professional aims.”
If Cassie had been sworn to silence, that promise didn’t last. By April 4, the Herald was airing its suspicion that a meeting with the heirs’ attorneys had been held, and that Cassie had “confessed it all.” By April 6, Cassie, Daskam, and Cohen (and apparently Baker) were all in custody — Cassie for perjury, and the lawyers and Daskam for subornation of perjury. The following day, however, Cohen and Baker were out on bail, and Daskam had hot-footed it to Connecticut.

Cassie, however, remained stuck behind bars at the Ludlow Street Jail, unable to post the required $2,500 bail. But custody seemed to agree with her. “She pranced about Police Headquarters,” the Herald reported on April 8, “and helped the matron wash, dress, and feed half a dozen lost children.” A police inspector called her “the most entertaining and sprightly lodger this roof has sheltered for a long time,” adding that he didn’t think Cassie was “at all anxious to get away.” A June 29 update assured readers she was “a great favorite at the jail, because she can sing like a lark and is docile and good natured.”
The Herald reporter did manage to secure another interview with Cassie that July, while she was still behind bars. She’d been promised somewhere between $10,000 and $150,000 as her share of the loot from Robertson’s estate, she confessed. Her directions had been simply to “play the part of the widow, to look sad, to weep occasionally, and above all to keep her mouth shut.”
It’s unclear what deal the prosecution eventually cut with Cassie, but she was released in August on a reduced bail of $1,000, presumably accompanied by her promise to return as a witness against Cohen if he should ever be picked up on his warrant.
And there, sadly, the rest of the story grows more or less cold.
Gould’s dive on 23rd Street was dismantled in January, 1892, after a fatal shooting forced its closure and all of its fixtures and furniture were sold at auction. A large picture of Gould himself “that used to adorn the place” was reportedly removed before the sale, “for fear that it might fall into the hands of somebody who would not appreciate it.” The pet monkey and the cat sold for $15.

Scheming attorney Byron W. Cohen was discovered in 1894, using the pseudonym Joe B. Morris and “living in great style” in Toronto, where he had drifted after previously going to Mexico. According to the Detroit News, “Morris” had arrived in Canada in July 1892, bringing with him “his mighty cheek and a little capital,” and somehow elevating himself to manager of a Toronto theater. Just what happened to him after that is unclear, but a woman named Estelle Fawcett was said to be greatly aggrieved to have “just discovered that he had another wife.”
Cassie Brooks was released from her bond obligation in December, 1899, with Cohen and Daskam still in the wind. I haven’t been able to definitively trace Cassie’s steps any further. But remember that her maiden name may have been “Leigh”? The 1900 Census shows an entry for a Cassie “Lee” of roughly the right age, divorced, and working as a servant in a household in Cayuga County, New York.
As for Loring Robertson’s rightful heirs, they would face one final twist. In December, 1891, just as they thought they were finally ready to settle the estate and divide the millionaire’s assets . . . a group of cousins in Glade Run, Pennsylvania petitioned the court to decide whether Robertson was actually legally domiciled in Pennsylvania (where a tannery was located), rather than New York – a claim which, if proven, would entitle additional heirs to share in the estate. The State of Pennsylvania also stepped into the proceedings with its own claim for $150,000 in inheritance taxes.
In the end, there was apparently simply too much money to fight over. In February, 1892, a Pennsylvania newspaper reported that the heirs had decided not to waste any more of the estate on lawyers, agreeing instead to split Loring Robertson’s approximately $3 million estate roughly equally among his New York and Pennsylvania relatives.
